Skip to content 
Thread Milling vs. Tapping: Mastering Precision Threads with Mills
Thread milling is a sophisticated machining technique that plays a crucial role in creating precise threads on workpieces. With the advent of thread mills and advanced threading tools, this process has become more efficient and accurate than ever before. In this article, we’ll explore the differences between thread milling and tapping techniques. Learn how to achieve accurate and precise threads using advanced mills for your machining needs.
What is a thread mill?
Thread milling is a machining process in which a tool rotates in a circular motion to cut internal and external threads of different sizes. The thread pitch is formed by the axial movement.
Thread milling cutters with indexable inserts are typically used for larger workpieces, while solid carbide thread milling cutters are used for smaller sized threaded holes.
This process produces high-quality threads in a wide range of materials and hole diameters, with a choice of left- or right-hand threads and a wide range of thread tolerances. Thread milling is used less frequently than tapping, but it is much more efficient for specific machining.
Key Points about thread mill:
Process Principle: In thread milling, the thread mill cutter spirals along the workpiece, cutting the thread profile with each rotation. The tool’s radial movement creates a continuous helical path that gradually forms the threaded pattern.
Material Compatibility: Thread milling can be applied to a wide range of materials, including metals, plastics, and composites. The process is suitable for both internal and external threads.
Thread Variability: Thread milling allows for the creation of threads with various sizes, pitches, and profiles. It’s particularly useful for specialized or custom threads that might not be readily available through standard threading methods.
Precision and Accuracy: The threading tool offers high precision and accuracy, making it ideal for applications where tight tolerances are required.
Tool Design: Thread mill cutters have multiple flutes with teeth designed to cut in a helical pattern. These teeth remove material gradually, producing smooth and consistent threads.
Chip Evacuation: Effective chip evacuation is essential during thread milling to prevent chip buildup and potential tool breakage. Proper coolant or lubrication helps manage chip removal.
CNC Machining: Thread milling is often performed using computer numerical control (CNC) machines, which accurately control the tool’s movements and cutting parameters.
Complex Threads: Thread milling can create threads with complex geometries, such as multi-start threads, worms, and specialized profiles.
Tool Longevity: Properly maintained thread mill cutters can have a longer tool life compared to taps, as the load is distributed across multiple teeth.
Thread Milling vs. Tapping
Thread mills and tapping are two common methods used to create threads on workpieces. Each method has its advantages and disadvantages, making them suitable for different scenarios. Here’s a comparison of thread milling and tapping:
Thread Milling:
Process: In thread milling, a rotating tool moves along a helical path to gradually cut threads into the workpiece.
Advantages:
Versatility: Can create various thread sizes and types.
Complex Threads: Capable of producing intricate thread profiles.
Strong Threads: Generates threads with even stress distribution.
Reduced Tool Wear: Multiple cutting edges result in longer tool life.
Custom Threads: Suited for specialized or custom threads.
Bottom Threads: Can create threads close to hole bottoms.
Chip Control: Efficient chip evacuation due to helical movement.
Disadvantages:
Slower for Standard Threads: May be slower than tapping for standard threads.
Initial Cost: Thread mill cutters can be costlier than taps.
Tapping:
Process: In tapping, a tap is used to cut threads by making repeated axial movements into the workpiece.
Advantages:
Faster for Standard Threads: Tapping is generally faster for standard threads.
Simplicity: Simple process, especially for standard threads.
Lower Initial Cost: Taps are often more affordable than thread mill cutters.
Quick Changeover: Tapping requires minimal setup time.
Disadvantages:
Limited Threads: This may not handle non-standard or complex threads well.
Axial Forces: High axial forces can lead to tap breakage, especially in harder materials.
Thread Quality: Threads may not be as precise in some cases.
Tool Wear: Single-tooth taps wear faster than thread mill cutters.
Bottom Threads: Challenging to create threads close to hole bottoms.
Main types of thread milling cutters
Single-tip, partially contoured thread milling cutters
The single point of contact reduces cutting forces, making it ideal for applications that require minimal side-cutting pressure and large L/D ratios.
Partial profile allows a variety of pitches, diameters and root cutoffs to be achieved with the same cutter.
Multi-tooth full tooth thread milling cutters
Easier to use because the cutting tool guarantees the final shape of the thread profile.
Cycle times are shortened because multiple teeth can be applied simultaneously.
Helical Fluted Thread Mills
High speed applications necessitate the use of helical fluted thread milling cutters. Due to the helical design, less pressure is required during cutting, resulting in a better surface finish on the workpiece, ideal for machining more complex and thin-walled materials.
Straight Groove Thread Milling Cutter
They are typically used for internal and external thread cutting. Each thread has one tooth on each face. They are considered best suited for rigid setups and robust, fast cutting.
Chamfering thread milling cutters
When countersunk holes or chamfers are also required, several suppliers now offer thread milling cutters with integrated countersunk holes in the head of the thread milling cutter, eliminating the need for users to change tools.
Choosing Between Thread Milling and Tapping
Material and Thread Type: Thread mill cutter is better for complex threads and non-standard sizes while tapping is faster for standard threads in softer materials.
Efficiency: For mass production of standard threads, tapping is often more efficient due to its faster cycle times.
Accuracy: Thread milling provides higher accuracy and better thread quality, making it suitable for precise applications.
Tool Longevity: Thread milling tools last longer due to multiple cutting edges, reducing tool change frequency.
Versatility: If your project involves diverse thread types or custom threads, thread milling offers more versatility.
Initial Cost: Taps have a lower initial cost, making them suitable for simpler applications.
FAQs
Q: Can thread mills create threads of various profiles?
A: Yes, thread mills can create different thread profiles, including V-threads and buttress threads.
Q: Is thread milling suitable for blind holes?
A: Absolutely, thread milling is highly effective for creating threads in blind holes.
Q: What materials can be threaded using thread mills?
A: Thread mills can be used on a wide range of materials, including metals, plastics, and composites.
Q: Are thread mills suitable for high-production environments?
A: Yes, thread mills are suitable for both low- and high-production environments due to their efficiency and accuracy.
Q: Can thread mills be used in CNC machines?
A: Yes, thread milling is well-suited for CNC machines and can be programmed for precise thread creation.
Thread milling has revolutionized the process of creating threads, offering enhanced precision, versatility, and efficiency. By understanding the intricacies of thread mills, their types, and best practices, machinists can achieve exceptional results in their threading endeavors.
